Did Hitler Really Commit Suicide?
19 April 2014
Hitler essentially helped secure a win by the Allied powers when he committed suicide in April of 1945. Having survived an assassination plot and having been responsible for the deaths of millions, many were ready for his departure from this realm. Now, the FBI has released information which is very unsettling to those assured by his death. It seems, in fact, that Hitler may have remained very much alive having simply faked his suicide, moving to Argentina to escape a losing war.
It seems impossible that Hitler faked his suicide, as he was found by Russian soldiers who then transported his body to their home nation. If this is to be untrue, it means that he was not the only one acting in secret. For him to survive, he would have to have been in collusion with at least one of the Allied powers by the end of the war in 1945.
According to the files now opened by the Federal Bureau of Investigation, a German submarine was seen making a Nazi personnel transport to Argentina shortly after the suicide. The files also suggest that these personnel were alive at the foot of the Andes with complete awareness by the United States. This, in combination with the fact that other files suggest Hitler never actually killed himself, is shocking to those who feel they know their government.
This information all comes from an unidentified informant who was granted amnesty for what he knew of Hitler. Their information suggests that Argentina not only knew about, but supported, the dictator’s decision to hide out in their lands. While it does seem convenient for the informant to gain amnesty for information that stands against what most know to be true, he seemed to know specific details about the faked suicide as well as the exact location of the dictator’s residence in Argentina, the Red Flag News reports.
The fact that Hitler committed suicide is one generally only questioned by conspiracy theorists, but this information from the FBI is disturbing to many who would not normally question what they read in their history books. This is not a completely new plausibility, as the corpse obtained by the Soviets has been tested before and did not appear to be genuine. Now that the FBI has released eyewitness testimonies, architectural plans for the home he moved into, and information that apparently was given to them decades ago, the theory is moving frighteningly close to fact. The most frightening notion potentially revealed is that not only did Hitler probably not commit suicide, but his escape may have been aided by the FBI itself.
Adolf Hitler killed himself by gunshot on 30 April 1945 in his Führerbunker in Berlin.
"... Günsche stated he entered the study to inspect the bodies, and observed Hitler ... sat ... sunken over, with blood dripping out of his right temple. He had shot himself with his own pistol, a PPK 7.65".
-- Fischer, Thomas [2008] "Soldiers of the Leibstandarte". Winnipeg: J.J. Fedorowicz
"... Blood dripped from a bullet hole in his right temple ..."
-- Kershaw, Ian [2001] "Hitler, 1936–1945: Nemesis 2". London: Penguin
"...30 April ... During the afternoon Hitler shot himself..."
-- MI5 staff [2011] "Hitler's Last Days". Her Majesty's Security Service website
His wife Eva [née Braun] committed suicide with him by taking cyanide.
"... her lips puckered from the poison".
-- Beevor, Antony [2002] "Berlin – The Downfall 1945". New York: Viking-Penguin
"That afternoon, in accordance with Hitler's prior instructions, their remains were carried up the stairs through the Bunker's emergency exit, doused in petrol, and set alight in the Reich Chancellery garden outside the Bunker. Records in the Soviet archives show that their burnt remains were recovered and interred in successive locations until 1970, when they were again exhumed, cremated, and the ashes scattered.
"... [the bodies] were deposited initially in an unmarked grave in a forest far to the west of Berlin, reburied in 1946 in a plot of land in Magdeburg."
-- Kershaw, Ian [2008] "Hitler: A Biography". New York: W. W. Norton & Company
"In 1970 the Kremlin finally disposed of the body in absolute secrecy ... body ... was exhumed and burned."
-- Beevor, Antony [2002]. "Berlin – The Downfall 1945". New York: Viking-Penguin
Accounts differ as to the cause of death; one states that he died by poison only and another that he died by a self-inflicted gunshot while biting down on a cyanide capsule.
"... both committing suicide by biting their cyanide ampoules."
-- Erickson, John [1983] "The Road to Berlin: Stalin's War with Germany: Volume 2". London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson
"... we have a fair answer ... to the version of ... Russian author Lev Bezymenski ... Hitler did shoot himself and did bite into the cyanide capsule, just as Professor Haase had clearly and repeatedly instructed ... "
-- O'Donnell, James P. [2001] "The Bunker". New York: Da Capo Press
Contemporary historians have rejected these accounts as being either Soviet Propaganda or an attempted compromise in order to reconcile the different conclusions.
"... New versions of Hitler's fate were presented by the Soviet Union according to the political needs of the moment ..."
-- Eberle, Henrik; Uhl, Matthias, eds. [2005] "The Hitler Book: The Secret Dossier Prepared for Stalin from the Interrogations of Hitler's Personal Aides". New York: Public Affairs.
"The intentionally misleading account of Hitler's death by cyanide poisoning put about by Soviet historians ... can be dismissed".
-- Kershaw, Ian [2001] "Hitler, 1936–1945: Nemesis 2". London: Penguin
"... most Soviet accounts have held that Hitler also [Hitler and Eva Braun] ended his life by poison ... there are contradictions in the Soviet story ... these contradictions tend to indicate that the Soviet version of Hitler's suicide has a political colouration".
-- Fest, Joachim C. [1974]. "Hitler". New York: Harcourt
One eye-witness recorded that the body showed signs of having been shot through the mouth, but this has been proven unlikely.
"Deep in the Lubyanka, headquarters of Russia's secret police, a fragment of Hitler's jaw is preserved as a trophy of the Red Army's victory over Nazi Germany. A fragment of skull with a bullet hole lies in the State Archive".
-- Halpin, Tony; Boyes, Roger [9 December 2009]. 'Battle of Hitler's skull prompts Russia to reveal all' - "The Times". Archived from the original on 29 June 2011.
There is also controversy regarding the authenticity of skull and jaw fragments which were recovered.
"... the only thing to remain of Hitler was a gold bridge with porcelain facets from his upper jaw and the lower jawbone with some teeth and two bridges".
-- Joachimsthaler, Anton [1999]. "The Last Days of Hitler: The Legends, The Evidence, The Truth". London: Brockhampton Press
"Hitler's jaws ... had been retained by SMERSH, while the NKVD kept the cranium."
-- Beevor, Antony [2002]. "Berlin – The Downfall 1945". New York: Viking-Pengui
In 2009, American researchers performed DNA tests on a skull Soviet officials had long believed to be Hitler's. The tests and examination revealed that the skull was actually that of a woman less than 40 years old. The jaw fragments which had been recovered were not tested.
"Deep in the Lubyanka, headquarters of Russia's secret police, a fragment of Hitler's jaw is preserved as a trophy of the Red Army's victory over Nazi Germany. A fragment of skull with a bullet hole lies in the State Archive".
-- Halpin, Tony; Boyes, Roger [9 December 2009\. 'Battle of Hitler's skull prompts Russia to reveal all' - "The Times". Archived from the original on 29 June 2011.
At the afternoon situation conference on 22 April 1945, Hitler suffered a total nervous collapse when he was informed that the orders he had issued the previous day for SS-General Felix Steiner's Army Detachment Steiner to move to the rescue of Berlin had not been obeyed. Hitler launched a tirade against the treachery and incompetence of his commanders, culminating in a declaration—for the first time—that the war was lost. Hitler announced that he would stay in Berlin until the end, and then shoot himself. Later that day he asked SS physician Dr. Werner Haase about the most reliable method of suicide. Haase suggested the "pistol-and-poison method" of combining a dose of cyanide with a gunshot to the head. When Field Marshal and head of the Luftwaffe Hermann Göring learned about this, he sent a telegram to Hitler asking for permission to take over the leadership of the Reich in accordance with Hitler's 1941 decree naming Göring his successor. Hitler's influential secretary, Martin Bormann, convinced Hitler that Göring was threatening a coup. In response, Hitler informed Göring that he would be executed unless he resigned all of his posts. Later that day, he sacked Göring from all of his offices and ordered his arrest.
By 27 April, Berlin was cut off from the rest of Germany. Secure radio communications with defending units had been lost; the command staff in the Bunker had to depend on telephone lines for passing instructions and orders and on public radio for news and information. On 28 April, a BBC report originating from Reuters was picked up; a copy of the message was given to Hitler. The report stated that Reichsführer-SS Heinrich Himmler had offered to surrender to the western Allies; the offer had been declined. Himmler had implied to the Allies that he had the authority to negotiate a surrender; Hitler considered this treason. During the afternoon his anger and bitterness escalated into a rage against Himmler. Hitler ordered Himmler's arrest and had Hermann Fegelein [Himmler's SS representative at Hitler's headquarters in Berlin] shot.
By this time, the Red Army had advanced to the Potsdamerplatz, and all indications were that they were preparing to storm the Chancellery. This report, combined with Himmler's treachery, prompted Hitler to make the last decisions of his life. After midnight on 29 April, Hitler married Eva Braun in a small civil ceremony in a map room within the Führerbunker.
"In the small hours of 28–29 April ... "
-- MI5 staff [2011] "Hitler's Last Days". Her Majesty's Security Service website
Afterwards Hitler hosted a modest wedding breakfast with his new wife. Hitler then took secretary Traudl Junge to another room and dictated his last will and testament. He signed these documents at 04:00 and then retired to bed [some sources say Hitler dictated the last will and testament immediately before the wedding, but all sources agree on the timing of the signing].
Using sources available to Trevor Roper [a World War II MI5 agent and historian/author of "The Last Days of Hitler"], MI5 records the marriage as taking place after Hitler had dictated the last will and testament.
Beevor records the marriage as taking place before Hitler had dictated the last will and testament.
-- Beevor, Antony [2002] "Berlin – The Downfall 1945". New York: Viking-Penguin
During the course of 29 April, Hitler learned of the death of his ally, Benito Mussolini, who had been executed by Italian partisans. Mussolini's body and that of his mistress, Clara Petacci, had been strung up by their heels. The bodies were later cut down and thrown in the gutter, where vengeful Italians reviled them. It is probable that these events strengthened Hitler's resolve not to allow himself or his wife to be made "a spectacle of", as he had earlier recorded in his Testament. That afternoon, Hitler expressed doubts about the cyanide capsules he had received through Himmler's SS. To verify the capsules' potency, Hitler ordered Dr. Werner Haase to test one on his dog, Blondi, and the animal died as a result.
Hitler and Braun lived together as husband and wife in the Bunker for fewer than 40 hours. By 01:00 on 30 April General Wilhelm Keitel reported that all forces which Hitler had been depending on to come to the rescue of Berlin had either been encircled or forced onto the defensive. Late in the morning of 30 April, with the Soviets less than 500 metres [1,600 ft] from the Bunker, Hitler had a meeting with General Helmuth Weidling, commander of the Berlin Defence Area, who told him that the garrison would probably run out of ammunition that night and that the fighting in Berlin would inevitably come to an end within the next 24 hours. Weidling asked Hitler for permission for a breakout, a request he had made unsuccessfully before. Hitler did not answer, and Weidling went back to his headquarters in the Bendlerblock. At about 13:00 he received Hitler's permission to try a breakout that night. Hitler, two secretaries, and his personal cook then had lunch, after which Hitler and Braun said farewell to members of the Führerbunker staff and fellow occupants, including Bormann, Josef Göbbels and his family, the secretaries, and several military officers. At around 14:30 Adolf and Eva Hitler went into Hitler's personal study.
Several witnesses later reported hearing a loud gunshot at around 15:30. After waiting a few minutes, Hitler's valet, Heinz Linge, with Bormann at his side, opened the study door. Linge later stated he immediately noted a scent of burnt almonds, a common observation made in the presence of prussic acid, the aqueous form of hydrogen cyanide. Hitler's adjutant, SS-Sturmbannführer Otto Günsche, entered the study and found the lifeless bodies on the sofa. Eva, with her legs drawn up, was to Hitler's left and slumped away from him. Günsche stated that Hitler "... sat ... sunken over, with blood dripping out of his right temple. He had shot himself with his own pistol, a Walther PPK 7.65". The gun lay at his feet and according to SS-Oberscharführer Rochus Misch, Hitler's head was lying on the table in front of him. Blood dripping from Hitler's right temple and chin had made a large stain on the right arm of the sofa and was pooling on the carpet. According to Linge, Eva's body had no visible physical wounds, and her face showed how she had died—cyanide poisoning.
"Cyanide poisoning. Its 'bite' was marked in her features".
-- Linge, Heinz [2009]. "With Hitler to the End". Frontline Books–Skyhorse Publishing
Günsche and SS-Brigadeführer Wilhelm Mohnke stated "unequivocally" that all outsiders and those performing duties and work in the Bunker "did not have any access" to Hitler's private living quarters during the time of death [between 15:00 and 16:00].
Günsche left the study and announced that the Führer was dead. The two bodies were carried up the stairs to ground level and through the Bunker's emergency exit to the garden behind the Reich Chancellery, where they were doused with petrol. An eye-witness, Rochus Misch, reported someone shouting "Hurry upstairs, they're burning the boss!" After the first attempts to ignite the petrol did not work, Linge went back inside the Bunker and returned with a thick roll of papers. Bormann lit the papers and threw the torch onto the bodies. As the two corpses caught fire, a small group, including Bormann, Günsche, Linge, Göbbels, Erich Kempka, Peter Högl, Ewald Lindloff, and Hans Reisser, raised their arms in salute as they stood just inside the Bunker doorway.
At around 16:15, Linge ordered SS-Untersturmführer Heinz Krüger and SS-Oberscharführer Werner Schwiedel to roll up the rug in Hitler's study to burn it. Schwiedel later stated that upon entering the study, he saw a pool of blood the size of a "large dinner plate" by the arm-rest of the sofa. Noticing a spent cartridge case, he bent down and picked it up from where it lay on the rug about 1 mm from a 7.65 pistol. The two men removed the blood-stained rug, carried it up the stairs and outside to the Chancellery garden. There the rug was placed on the ground and burned.
On and off during the afternoon, the Soviets shelled the area in and around the Reich Chancellery. SS guards brought over additional cans of petrol to further burn the corpses. Linge later noted the fire did not completely destroy the remains, as the corpses were being burned in the open, where the distribution of heat varies. The burning of the corpses lasted from 16:00 to 18:30. The remains were covered up in a shallow bomb crater at around 18:30 by Lindloff and Reisser.
The first inkling to the outside world that Hitler was dead came from the Germans themselves. On 1 May the radio station Reichssender Hamburg interrupted their normal program to announce that an important broadcast would soon be made. After dramatic funereal music by Wagner and Bruckner, Grand Admiral Karl Dönitz [appointed as Hitler's successor in his will] announced that Hitler was dead. Dönitz called upon the German people to mourn their Führer, who died a hero defending the capital of the Reich. Hoping to save the army and the nation by negotiating a partial surrender to the British and Americans, Dönitz authorized a fighting withdrawal to the west. His tactic was somewhat successful: it enabled about 1.8 million German soldiers to avoid capture by the Soviets, but it came at a high cost in bloodshed, as troops continued to fight until 8 May.
On the morning of 1 May, thirteen hours after the event, Stalin was informed of Hitler's suicide. General Hans Krebs had given this information to Soviet General Vasily Chuikov when they met at 04:00 on 1 May, when the Germans attempted to negotiate acceptable surrender terms.[44][45] Stalin demanded unconditional surrender and asked for confirmation that Hitler was dead. He wanted Hitler's corpse found. In the early morning hours of 2 May, the Soviets captured the Reich Chancellery. Down in the Führerbunker, General Krebs and General Wilhelm Burgdorf committed suicide by gunshot to the head
Later on 2 May, the remains of Hitler, Braun, and two dogs [thought to be Blondi and her offspring, Wulf] were discovered in a shell crater by a unit of the Red Army intelligence agency SMERSH tasked with finding Hitler's body. Stalin was still wary about believing his old nemesis was dead, and restricted what information could be publicly released. The remains of Hitler and Braun were repeatedly buried and exhumed by SMERSH during the unit's relocation from Berlin to a new facility in Magdeburg. The bodies, along with the charred remains of propaganda minister Göbbels, his wife Magda, and their six children, were buried in an unmarked grave beneath a paved section of the front courtyard. The location was kept secret.
Different versions of Hitler's fate were presented by the Soviet Union according to its political desires. In the years immediately following 1945, the Soviets maintained Hitler was not dead, but had fled and was being shielded by the former western allies. This worked for a time to create doubt among western authorities. The chief of the U.S. trial counsel at Nuremberg, Thomas J. Dodd, said: "No one can say he is dead." When President Harry S. Truman asked Stalin at the Potsdam Conference in August 1945 whether or not Hitler was dead, Stalin replied bluntly, "No". But by 11 May 1945, the Soviets had already confirmed through Hitler's dentist, Hugo Blaschke, and his dental technician that the dental remains found were Hitler's and Braun's. In November 1945, Dick White, then head of counter-intelligence in the British sector of Berlin [and later head of MI5 and MI6 in succession], had their agent Hugh Trevor-Roper investigate the matter to counter the Soviet claims. His findings were written in a report and published in book form in 1947.
In May 1946, SMERSH agents recovered from the crater where Hitler was buried two burned skull fragments with gunshot damage. These remains were apparently forgotten in the Russian State Archives until 1993, when they were re-found. In 2009 DNA and forensic tests were performed on the skull fragment, which Soviet officials had long believed to be Hitler's. According to the American researchers, the tests revealed that the skull was actually that of a woman and the examination of the sutures where the skull plates come together placed her age at less than 40 years old. The jaw fragments which had been recovered in May 1945 were not tested.
In 1969, Soviet journalist Lev Bezymensky's book on the death of Hitler was published in the West. It included the SMERSH autopsy report, but because of the earlier disinformation attempts, western historians thought it untrustworthy.
In 1970, the SMERSH facility, by then controlled by the KGB, was scheduled to be handed over to the East German government. Fearing that a known Hitler burial site might become a Neo-Nazi shrine, KGB director Yuri Andropov authorised an operation to destroy the remains that had been buried in Magdeburg on 21 February 1946. A Soviet KGB team was given detailed burial charts. On 4 April 1970 they secretly exhumed five wooden boxes containing the remains of "10 or 11 bodies ... in an advanced state of decay". The remains were thoroughly burned and crushed, after which the ashes were thrown into the Biederitz river, a tributary of the nearby Elbe.
"... the ashes were flushed into the town [Magdeburg] sewage system."
-- Beevor, Antony [2002]. "Berlin – The Downfall 1945". New York: Viking-Penguin